Thursday, October 27, 2011

Multiculturalism in the Curriculum Entry #4


In my last posting, I defined multiculturalism as “the preservation of different cultures or cultural identities within a unified society, as a state or nation” (Multiculturalism, n.d.).   Multiculturalism is becoming extremely prevalent in the United States because the population is becoming more and more culturally diverse.  Therefore, the public schools in the U.S. are experiencing the same results.  The Staff at GreatSchools.org indicate that children can be better prepared for a multicultural democracy by attending a school with a diverse student body (GreatSchools Staff, n.d.).  How do we help the children learn to respect and appreciate the cultures of their fellow classmates?  As educators, should we try to integrate multiculturalism into the curriculum?  If integrating multiculturalism into the curriculum is the right answer, then the next question is how do we perform this task without appearing to show favoritism to a particular group.

In an article in Education World, a former professor of multicultural education feels that incorporating multiculturalism into the existing curriculum is in fact the best way to teach multiculturalism (Newquist, 1997).  As I consider this concept, I think about a recent discussion that I recently had with some of my fellow classmates on multiculturalism in the classroom.  One opinion that I vividly remember is a classmate describing how teachers would only address a particular culture on a holiday or a specific month.  For example, Martin Luther King Day, Cinco de Mayo, or Thanksgiving.  In his article entitled Multiculturalism in School Curriculum, Adam Waxler (n.d.) states the following: “Having separate months for different cultures is exactly the opposite of what a true multicultural education should be trying to achieve.” 

What is the best approach to incorporate multiculturalism into the curriculum?  As I ponder on and research this question, I came across a statement made by the GreatSchools Staff that I referenced earlier.  They indicate the following:  “Teachers are faced with the challenge of making instruction “culturally responsive” for all students while not favoring one group over another” (GreatSchools Staff, n.d.).  Personally, I agree with Adam Waxler’s idea of how to appropriately apply this concept into the curriculum.  In his opinion, the teacher should use the traditional curriculum and incorporate various perspectives and different cultures within the various units into the traditional curriculum.  This is the way that he teaches multiculturalism without totally forgetting about the traditional curriculum.  For example, when he teaches a traditional curriculum topic such as the Vietnam War, he has his students examine the opinions of the war from the perspective of various groups of Americans from different races and genders (Waxler, n.d.).

As I reflect back to my childhood, I hardly remember learning anything about other cultures within my curriculum.  I lived in a rural area of Southern Tennessee.  The school that I attended was not at all culturally diverse.  There were very few students of another race or nationality.  Now that I think back on this time, I wonder how my fellow classmates felt about this especially the few that were considered the minority. 

In closing, I think that it is important to quote a statement from E.D. Hirsch, Jr. from his article Toward a Centrist Curriculum.  He states, “Children will become adults who cooperate and sustain one another only if the school-based culture they gain makes them feel they truly belong to the larger society” (Hirsch, 1992).




References

GreatSchools Staff. (n.d.).  How important is cultural diversity at your school?  Retrieved from http://www.greatschools.org/find-a-school/defining-your-ideal/284-cultural-diversity-at-school.gs

Hirsch, Jr. E.D.  (1992).  Toward a centrist curriculum:  Two kinds of multiculturalism in elementary school.  Retrieved from http://teachingcontent.org/mimik/mimik_uploads/documents/4/CentCurr.pdf

Multiculturalism.  (n.d.)  Retrieved October 11, 2011 from http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/multiculturalism

Newquist, C.  (1997).  Multiculturalism…Preparing students for a diverse and global society.  Education World.  Retrieved from http://www.educationworld.com/a_books/books001.shtml

Waxler, A.  (n.d.).  Multiculturalism in school curriculum.  Retrieved from http://www.eslteachersboard.com/cgi-bin/articles/index.pl?page=7;read=1621


Thursday, October 13, 2011

Multiculturalism and Diversity in the Classroom Entry #3

The dictionary defines multiculturalism as “the preservation of different cultures or cultural identities within a unified society, as a state or nation” (Multiculturalism, n.d.).  Initially, my thoughts regarding multiculturalism with regards to its dictionary meaning was that it is a great concept.  I think that it is important to identify and respect other cultures in our society.

Personally, I consider myself to be someone that respects all human beings no matter the gender, race, ethnicity, disability, age, etc.  I do not truly understand how anyone can discriminate against someone else on the basis of these factors.  Think about the following:  Do we really have a choice regarding our skin color?  No, we were born this way without being given a choice.  If we weren’t provided with the choice, how can we discriminate against this issue?

In the article entitled “Pithissippi Burning:  Race, White Nationalism and American Culture”, I found the comments regarding the cultural extremists quite disheartening.  It is hard to believe that anyone simply cannot accept someone for who they are on the inside instead of what they look like on the outside.  As the article indicates, individuals with these perceptions do still exist in our society (Tobia, 2009).

In the articles regarding why multiculturalism is wrong and the challenges multiculturalism imposes, the articles seemed to simply be stating that we should teach children only the context of their own particular culture (Taylor, n.d.; Why multiculturalism is wrong, n.d.).  At this point in my life, I simply do not agree with this ideology.  I may change my views later in life or once I am in the classroom; however, I currently simply do not agree.  I thought history was based on the facts of what occurred in the past whether those facts represent the African Americans, Chinese, Indians, etc.  The culture of the individuals simply should not matter.  The textbook should contain the important events that shaped our world if we are teaching world history, our nation if we are teaching US history, etc.  The books should not be defined based on the culture of the majority of the group.  I found an article written for PBS that contains a statement that helps reiterate the claim that we should be willing to learn and appreciate other cultures.  The following comments were made in the article: “We [should] also learn to collaborate across cultural lines as individuals and as a society.  Awareness of cultural differences doesn’t have to divide us from each other...Becoming more aware of our cultural differences, as well as exploring our similarities, can help us communicate with each other more effectively.  Recognizing where cultural differences are at work is the first step toward understanding and respecting each other” (DuPraw & Axner, n.d.).

Samuel Taylor makes an interesting comment in his article regarding the challenges of multiculturalism.  He compares multicultural history to Affirmative Action (Taylor, n.d.).  This may have been the original intent of Affirmative Action when the majority was simply having a hard time respecting the rights of the minority.  However, in 2011, the roles have somewhat reversed.  What was once considered the minority population in the US is now slowly increasing and catching up to the population numbers of the majority.  Now, some employers have to also be conscious of the possibilities of reverse discrimination.

Conversely, as a future teacher, I anticipate there will be several situations in which I will be faced with diversity issues in my classroom.  I hope that I am able to teach my students that no two people are exactly alike, and we should respect each others differences.  We may not agree with their opinions or actions, but we should at least respect them as human beings.

Why can’t we all just get along???


References


DuPraw, M.E. and Axner, M. (n.d.)  Working on common cross-cultural communication challenges.  Retrieved from http://www.pbs.org/ampu/crosscult.html#WORKING

Multiculturalism.  (n.d.)  Retrieved October 11, 2011 from http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/multiculturalism

Taylor, S.  (n.d.)  The challenge of multiculturalism in how American view the past and the future.  The Journal of Historical Review.  Retrieved from http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v12/v12p159_Taylor.html

Tobia, P.J. (2009).  Pithissippi burning: Race, white nationalism and American culture.  Retrieved from http://www.nashvillescene.com/pitw/archives/2009/02/23/pithissippi-burning-race-white-nationalism-and-american-culture

Why multiculturalism is wrong.  (n.d.).  Retrieved from http://web.inter.nl.net/users/Paul.Treanor/multicult.html